I am disappointed in Rep. Lee Nerison’s (R-Westby) vote against the Healthy Youth Act (AB 458).

As a retired educator, I cannot but feel that he let conservative ideology trump the evidence.

I am retired having over 30 years of experience, primarily as a guidance counselor, in three states (Michigan, Alaska, Wisconsin). As such, I was party to the issue of teenage sexuality and the ramifications thereof for most of my adult life, not to mention the experience of myself and those I knew as I entered adolescence and adulthood. This is one issue where the evidence from scientifically based studies and my own experiences over the years shows the moderate and more liberal approaches to be superior. Young people need the same information that of the developed world’s adults are privy to on the issues of human sexuality and family planning/birth control plus disease prevention.

Have you ever wondered why the Europeans in general, with their very liberal and open approach to their youth and sexuality have such a superior record relative to the United States? Research has shown that the rates of unwanted pregnancies, STD rates and abortion rates were much lower in Europe than in the States. I have had foreign exchange students at my own home and have interacted with many others during my years as an educator. Almost without exception, I found they had a much more mature respectful attitude about sex than our own kids. They showed very high levels of respect for their parents and sex than many, if not most, of our own students.

You are listening to a man who had Republican leanings most of his life — until the GOP came under the sway of the religious right folks. Social conservatives have destroyed the party for many of us. One of the primary reasons is the ideological purity the GOP seems to expect and its refusal to accept scientific research over outdated concepts.

I like Rep. Nerison. I have listened to him speak at veterans’ affairs and in other venues and there is much to like. He is a good man. I realize that good men stand on opposite sides of issues such as this — and, in their minds, they are all right.

All I am asking is that he listen to my thoughts and, perhaps, pay a bit more attention to the scientific research and the experiences of other cultures (Western Europe) in these regards.

Michael Dishnow

Soldiers Grove

The Broadcaster does not post blog comments regarding letters to the editor.